Directed by Michael Showalter   Written by Fenton Bailey   Randy Barbato   Abe Sylvia   Cast Jessica Chastain ... Tammy Faye Bakker Andrew Garfield ... Jim Bakker Cherry Jones ... Rachel Grover Vincent D'Onofrio ... Jerry Falwell Mark Wystrach ... Gary Paxton Sam Jaeger ... Roe Messner Louis Cancelmi ... Richard Fletcher Gabriel Olds ... Pat Robertson Fredric Lehne ... Fred Grover Chandler Head ... Little Tammy Faye Jay Huguley ... Jimmy Swaggart (as James Huguley) Dan Johnson ... Preacher Michael MacCauley ... Big Man Grant Owens ... Colonel Sanders Coley Campany ... Dede Robertson Craig Newkirk ... Doctor Wes Jetton ... Male Nurse Jess Weixler ... Makeup Artist (voice) Maurie Speed ... Nurse Lindsay Ayliffe ... Old Teacher (Bible College) Julie P. Tuggle ... Pledge Lady Kimberly Ann Parker ... Reporter Dana Marks ... True Believer Alan Boell ... Stephen Chow Randy Havens ... Steve Pieters Lila Jane Meadows ... Tammy Sue Carolyn Mints ... Wanda Kelly Borgnis ... PTL Patron Kelsi Chandler ... PTL Patron Joe Ando-Hirsh ... Teenage Punk #1 John Johnson ... Teenage Punk #2 Grayson Carter ... Teenage Punk #3 Callie Lipian ... Jamie Charles Bakker (Baby) Caroline Lipian ... Tammy Sue Bakker (Baby) Amanda Medina ... Self - Tammy Faye Dancer (archive footage), (credit only) Uncredited Cast Allen Andrews ... PTL Sax Player Wray Anthony ... Audience Member Sophia Bell ... CBN Kid Lluvia Bermudez ... PTL Crew Francesca Black ... Judy Mellie Boozer ... Tammy's Choir Member Elizabeth J Branca ... Jan Crouch Drew Broderick ... Parent (Audience) John Mark Brooks ... PTL Cameraman Amanda Camarena Burdier ... PTL Phone Bank Operator Tommy Campbell ... Falwell Preacher Jodie Castellani ... Church Lady Zach Catanzareti ... PTL Audience Member Bonnie Cole ... Phone Bank Operator Brian Cole ... Audience Member Tara Corinne ... Audience Member David Crary ... Phone Bank Operator Nic Curtis ... Camera Man / Fan Holder Jessica Deal ... PTL Member Jessica Nicole Donoso ... Wardrobe Lady Keith D Dooley ... Faculty Chris TC Edge ... PTL Backstage Crew Chris Emrich ... Mover BG Willie Tyrone Ferguson ... News Camera Man Brent Moorer Gaskins ... Choir Member / PTL Audience Member / Tammy Faye Dancer Christian Goins ... Little Danny Brent Gribble ... Dinner / Show Guest LaTesha Hines ... Audience Member Michelle Brown Houston   Kimberly Hester Huffstetler ... Congregation Member Tanya Jacobson ... Tanya Jacobson Daniel Johnson ... Photographer Dalton Johnston ... Concert Goer Christine A. Jordan ... Parent (Audience) Kenny Keen ... Oral Robert Audience / PTL Audience Jane Klecker ... Congregation Member / Phone Bank / Audience Juliana McCully ... PTL Phone Bank Operator Genevieve McDevitt ... PTL Mom Stephanie McIntyre ... PTL Bryan Metoyer ... Prison Visitor Taylor McCall Moore ... PTL Grayson Lloyd Murphy ... Extra Donald Norris Jr. ... Parent Audience Member Christopher W. Norris ... Couch Preacher Rigo Nova ... PTL Crew Kevin J. O'Connor ... PTL Crew Supervisor Patrick Ashley O'Neal ... Mover Abigail Dare Oliver ... Congregation Member Brandon Parker ... Prisoner Hailey Nicole Ralston ... Tammy's Family Tom Rascoe ... Falwell Preacher Kyle Riggs ... Jamie Charles Bakker Edward Rojas ... PTL Audience Member JeriAnne Rushing ... PTL Audience Member Kassidy Rushing ... PTL Audience Member Anne Schmitt ... PTL Show Guest on Stage Tamara Snegosky ... Special Guest Jonathan C Stephens ... European Pastor Joshua Stephens ... Audience member (archive footage) Emory Grace Ann Stewart ... CBN Child Bennett Tarr ... Phone Bank Operator LaChelle Walker ... PTL Crew Monica Walsh ... Phone Bank Operator Brian Welch ... Falwell's Man Klara Wilder ... Audience Member Kristel Wilder ... Audience Member Tyler Wojton ... Little Donny Produced by Adrian Alperovich   Fenton Bailey   Randy Barbato   Kelly Carmichael   Jessica Chastain   Jenny Hinkey   T.K. Knowles   Meredith Milton   Jordana Mollick   John O'Grady   Gigi Pritzker   Rachel Shane   Original Music by Theodore Shapiro

Additional Info Premiere: September 12, 2021 Theatrical Release: September 17, 2021 DVD Release: November 16, 2021 Countries: Distributor: Fox Searchlight Websites: Production Companies Searchlight Pictures (as Searchlight Pictures) Freckle Films MWM Studios Searchlight Pictures Semi-Formal Productions Distributors Searchlight Pictures   (2020) (USA) (theatrical) (through Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures) Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures   (2020) (USA) (theatrical) Rating Stats Overall Rating 6.6 / 10 Our Rating -- / 10 Your Friends -- / 10 Male Users -- / 10 Female Users -- / 10 Site Ranking #2,715 / 20,906 Site Ranking #2,711 Holmes & Watson (2018) #2,712 The Lawnmower Man (1992) #2,713 Nosferatu The Vampyre (1979) #2,714 Godzilla (1954) #2,715 The Eyes Of Tammy Faye (2021) #2,716 13 Sins (2014) #2,717 The Fog (2005) #2,718 Godzilla x Kong: The New Empire (2024) #2,719 The Muppet Movie (1979)